Review v1 · round 1 · manuscript v1
Acetylation of lysine 82 initiates TDP-43 nuclear loss of function by disrupting its nuclear import
Panel readout
5 specialists · scored 1–5
Legacy scaled score
Range 4.0–5.0, a spread of 1.0.
- ethics5.0Confidence 5 of 5
- data analysis4.0Confidence 4 of 5
- reporting reproducibility4.0Confidence 4 of 5
- scientific validity4.0Confidence 4 of 5
- contribution context4.0Confidence 4 of 5
Score is the referee's assessment of the work.Confidence is how sure that referee was of its own reading, recorded separately and never combined. The editor's verdict is its own judgment of the reports, not a threshold applied to this mean. The legacy aggregate is the historical panel mean multiplied by 20. It is not comparable to the Editor-in-Chief's publication readiness score.
Abstract
as posted by the authors
The hallmark of a spectrum of age-dependent neurodegenerative diseases, including Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis (ALS), is a TDP-43 proteinopathy that includes nuclear loss of function and cytoplasmic aggregation. Here, reduced proteasome activity, as naturally occurs during aging, is shown to inhibit nuclear import of TDP-43. Quantitative mass spectrometry is used to determine that TDP-43 is the protein whose nuclear localization is most perturbed upon reduction in proteasome activity, culminating in elevated cytoplasmic TDP-43. Interaction of importin-1 with the bipartite classical nuclear localization sequence (cNLS) of TDP-43 is shown to be disrupted by partial proteasome inhibition but maintained by replacement with a PY-NLS that is recognized by importin-{beta}2. Mechanistically, this nuclear depletion of TDP-43 is shown to be driven by ubiquitination or acetylation of lysines 79, 82, and 84 within the cNLS when proteasome activity is reduced in human neurons. Specifically, acetylation at lysine 82 is sufficient to abolish TDP-43 binding to importin-1 and subsequent nuclear import of TDP-43. Moreover, using acetylation-specific TDP-43 antibodies, we detected acetylation of lysine 82 in the motor cortex of sporadic ALS patients but not control subjects. Our findings demonstrate that post-translational acetylation at lysine 82 of TDP-43 drives disruption of its importin-1-mediated nuclear import and is sufficient to initiate TDP-43 nuclear loss of function and cytoplasmic accumulation, evidence supporting acetylation as a plausible initiator of TDP-43 proteinopathies.
The review
- SummaryThe panel's assessment in brief.
- Decision letterThe editor's verdict and what it requires.
- Desk screenWhether the submission cleared the bar for full review.
- Advocate / skeptic debateThe case for and against, in full.
- Debate synthesisThe condensed account of the debate the editor read.
- Venue suggestionsWhere this might be submitted.
- Manuscript statisticsDeterministic counts over the text the panel read.
Specialist reports
Editorial audits
Factual checklists, not opinions. They skip the debate and go straight to the editor.
The text the panel read
counted, not judged
Counted at ingest, no model involved. These describe theconverted text the referees read, not your PDF.
Size
- Words
- 9,171
- Main text
- 8,435
- Sentences
- 468
- Display equations
- 0
excluding references
Sentences
- Median sentence
- 17 words
- Longest tenth
- 44 words
- Over 40 words
- 12%
- Passive
- ~0.5/sentence
regex approximation
Evidence on the page
- Citations
- not countable
- Numbers
- 116.78
- p-values
- 0 exact, 5 threshold
this venue most likely sets them as superscript numerals, which convert to bare digits
per 1000 words
Hedging against amplifying
Per 1000 words. Softening ("may", "suggests") against strengthening ("clearly", "demonstrates"). No referee saw these.
Provenance
PeerReviewAgents 0.5.0 · 1cf57690
Reviewed file
v1 · 2188 KiB
sha256 ff43baa698e90c1fdbea0efc…
Debate rounds
2
Run cost
$1.72
Manuscript read as
markdown
Converted by rustypaper 0.2.0. Quotations match the manuscript text.
Desk screen
triage gate
Which model wrote which report
| Stage | Model |
|---|---|
| Editorial audits (×2) | claude-haiku-4-5 |
| Advocate / skeptic | claude-sonnet-5 |
| Specialist reviewers (×5) + desk screen | claude-haiku-4-5 |
| Editor, debate synthesizer | claude-opus-5 |
| debate synthesizer (override) | claude-sonnet-5 |
| journal recommender (override) | claude-haiku-4-5 |
The widest fan-out runs on the cheapest model. Only the agents that decide the verdict run on the most capable one.
What the referees looked up (23 searches)
| Agent | Search | Answered by | Hits |
|---|---|---|---|
| reviewer contribution context | find related workTDP-43 acetylation lysine nuclear localization | N/A | 10 |
| find related workTDP-43 nuclear import importin-alpha NLS | N/A | 10 | |
| find related workproteasome inhibition TDP-43 mislocalization | N/A | 10 | |
| search preprintsTDP-43 acetylation K82 nuclear import | N/A | 0 | |
| search biomedical literatureTDP-43 acetylation nuclear localization ALS | N/A | 9 | |
| search biomedical literatureTDP-43 importin nuclear import lysine | N/A | 2 | |
| search biomedical literatureCohen acetylation TDP-43 aggregation 2015 | N/A | 0 | |
| search biomedical literatureproteasome activity aging TDP-43 neurodegeneration | N/A | 10 | |
| search biomedical literatureCohen 2015 acetylation switch TDP-43 function aggregation Nature Communications | N/A | 0 | |
| search biomedical literatureDoll 2022 TDP-43 nuclear localization signal importin alpha beta Cell Reports | N/A | 0 | |
| search biomedical literatureKo 2024 acetylation-mimetic TDP-43 NLS importin alpha1 | N/A | 0 | |
| search biomedical literatureKametani mass spectrometry TDP-43 post-translational modifications ALS | N/A | 1 | |
| search biomedical literatureTDP-43 K82 acetylation lysine nuclear import disruption | N/A | 0 | |
| search biomedical literatureTDP-43 bipartite NLS classical nuclear localization sequence importin | N/A | 0 | |
| search biomedical literatureproteasome inhibition TDP-43 cytoplasmic accumulation nuclear depletion | N/A | 7 | |
| search biomedical literatureKo single acetylation-mimetic mutation TDP-43 NLS 2024 | N/A | 0 | |
| search biomedical literatureTDP-43 post-translational modifications acetylation ubiquitination phosphorylation | N/A | 2 | |
| search biomedical literatureGarcia Morato sirtuin lysine 136 acetylation TDP-43 phase separation | N/A | 1 | |
| search biomedical literatureCohen TJ acetylation switch TDP-43 2015 | N/A | 0 | |
| search biomedical literatureTDP-43 nuclear export passive diffusion export signals | N/A | 1 | |
| search biomedical literatureTDP-43 stathmin-2 splicing cryptic polyadenylation | N/A | 1 | |
| search biomedical literatureTDP-43 lysine arginine mutation NLS nuclear localization | N/A | 0 | |
| search biomedical literatureimportin alpha recognition bipartite NLS lysine charge | N/A | 0 |
Run against arXiv, Semantic Scholar, PubMed and bioRxiv while the review was being written. A search returning zero hits is kept: it is the evidence behind a referee saying it found no prior art.
What each agent cost
| Agent | USD |
|---|---|
| editor | $0.5857 |
| advocate | $0.3370 |
| skeptic | $0.2932 |
| reviewer contribution context | $0.1817 |
| debate synthesizer | $0.0877 |
| audit citation integrity | $0.0739 |
| desk screen | $0.0509 |
| audit methods completeness | $0.0398 |
| reviewer reporting reproducibility | $0.0156 |
| reviewer scientific validity | $0.0155 |
| reviewer data analysis | $0.0148 |
| journal recommender | $0.0134 |
| reviewer ethics | $0.0078 |
Cite this review
Permanent: this review only
This URL is a permanent link to this specific review, and will not change.
In Silico (2026). Review of "Acetylation of lysine 82 initiates TDP-43 nuclear loss of function by disrupting its nuclear import". In Silico. https://pgarrett-scripps.github.io/insilico/reviews/2024/acetylation-of-lysine-82-initiates-tdp-43-nuclear-10-1101-2024-09-04-611121/v1/
@misc{insilico-acetylation-of-lysine-82-initiates-tdp-43-nuclear-10-1101-2024-09-04-611121-v1,
title = {Review of {Acetylation of lysine 82 initiates TDP-43 nuclear loss of function by disrupting its nuclear import}},
author = {{In Silico}},
year = {2026},
howpublished = {In Silico, an AI-refereed overlay journal},
url = {https://pgarrett-scripps.github.io/insilico/reviews/2024/acetylation-of-lysine-82-initiates-tdp-43-nuclear-10-1101-2024-09-04-611121/v1/},
note = {Machine-generated peer review of doi:10.1101/2024.09.04.611121 v1. Produced by PeerReviewAgents 0.5.0. Produced by PeerReviewAgents, doi:10.5281/zenodo.21781895.}
}Please cite the preprint itself as well. This reviews that work, it does not replace it. The review is machine-generated and advisory. If you are citing it as evidence about the paper, say so explicitly.